America Politics

Watchdogs support Musk’s goal of tackling fraud — but question the way DOGE is doing it

The Department of Government Efficiency has needlessly politicized the urgent issue of improper spending and could make real changes harder…
Watchdogs support Musk’s goal of tackling fraud — but question the way DOGE is doing it
Send to

The Department of Government Efficiency has needlessly politicized the urgent issue of improper spending and could make real changes harder, several experts said.

For decades, government watchdogs and budget oversight experts have been trying to get someone — anyone — to listen to them about the need to root out waste, fraud and abuse in federal spending, frustrated that their calls for systemic change were going unheard by Washington.

Many were cautiously optimistic when President Donald Trump empowered billionaire Elon Musk to bring improper spending under control and to modernize outrageously outdated federal payments systems.

But in interviews with half a dozen of these watchdogs, most said this isn’t what they had in mind.

The breakneck upheaval of federal agencies spearheaded by Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency, or DOGE, has needlessly politicized the issue and could make it harder to enact the real changes needed to root out improper spending, five good-government experts said.

“Elon Musk is saying we’ve got shocking amounts of fraud, and you’re right, we do. No one’s really cared until now,” said fraud prevention expert Linda Miller, a former senior staff member for Congress’ independent Government Accountability Office during the George W. Bush and Barack Obama administrations.

“But the examples they’re bringing are silly, made-for-TV red meat, made for people to be amazed and horrified and shocked,” Miller continued, pointing to some diversity, equity and inclusion-related arts projects on the White House’s list of objectionable U.S. Agency for International Development programs, some of which weren’t actually funded by the agency. “It makes the government sound like it’s a mockery.”

Trump defended DOGE’s efforts during a press briefing with Musk this week, saying without specifics that the group has unearthed “billions and billions of dollars in waste, fraud and abuse.” The White House did not respond to a request for comment.

Miller and other oversight experts said Musk has highlighted some legitimate, long-standing problems that the federal government has failed to address under both parties. Among them are the need to improve the government’s “Do Not Pay” system to check whether people are deceased or barred from receiving federal payments because they are blocked foreign nationals from countries under U.S. sanctions, for example.

Posting on X, Musk noted the need for the “Do Not Pay” system’s list of ineligible people to be updated far more frequently, among other oversight changes he has proposed. “There’s crazy things, like, just a cursory examination of Social Security and we’ve got people in there that are about 150 years old,” Musk said during a Wednesday press briefing.

The experts also pointed to the staggering scale of the problem. Last year, the Government Accountability Office said that in 2023, the federal government made an estimated $236 billion in improper payments, which includes those that were higher and lower than they should have been.

“There is absolutely waste, fraud and abuse, and there are improper payments, and there are inefficiencies,” said Dylan Hedtler-Gaudette, director of government affairs at the Project On Government Oversight, a nonpartisan watchdog group. “And they just come up with all kinds of reasons that basically come down to ‘It’s too hard, and we don’t want to do it.’”

At a House oversight hearing this week, Hedtler-Gaudette and other expert witnesses proposed improving tracking and reporting requirements for federal spending and strengthening identity and asset verification, among other changes, mentioning massive fraud in Covid relief programs as evidence of the pressing need for change.

Oversight experts say there is an important distinction between potential criminal activity like fraud and self-dealing and the far broader, inherently subjective category of waste — a difference that has often gotten muddied in the administration’s claims about its cost-cutting efforts.

Recommended Article Haley Joel Osment Reveals He Has Been Living With Sister Emily Osment After the L.A. Fires

Both Musk and Trump have claimed that DOGE has unearthed sweeping fraud and corruption inside federal agencies without providing specific evidence. Instead, the official DOGE website has largely highlighted the elimination of “wasteful contracts” related to DEI, climate change, consulting and media.

“Waste is in the eye of the beholder — that’s a political issue,” said Bob Westbrooks, a former inspector general for the federal government during the Obama and first Trump administrations. “We’re conflating the difference between waste and fraud, I think, in an irresponsible and reckless way. It’s causing agencies to be shut down. It’s causing people to lose their jobs.”

The Trump administration has cited the problem of widespread government “waste, fraud and abuse” in its efforts to halt the work of USAID, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and other agencies, as well as to lay off thousands of federal employees. DOGE’s rapid efforts to upend agencies prompted a wave of legal challenges alleging a lack of transparency and data privacy violations; the lawsuits are pending.

Some oversight experts and budget watchdogs have welcomed Musk’s effort given the deep-seated failures of the federal government to solve the real problems with improper payments.

“The tire has so many holes in it — you can’t fix it anymore,” said Haywood Talcove, CEO of LexisNexis Risk Solutions for Government, an anti-fraud company, who also testified before Congress on the issue this week. “You’ve got people that are just brilliant — they’ve done things that others haven’t. I would give them a whack at it.”

Haywood stressed, though, that the overarching goal should be not only to prevent improper payments like fraud, but also to ensure that government works for those who deserve federal assistance and have been stymied by bureaucratic hurdles.

“People depend on government — government is super important, and nobody wants to be tortured with systems and processes,” he said. “Anyone who can fix this we need to have in there.”

But others warned that tearing apart federal agencies in the name of rooting out improper spending could end up backfiring, both by undermining DOGE’s credibility and encouraging Trump and Musk’s critics to overlook the real problem of improper spending.

“The way to do this is not go in and break things,” said Steve Ellis, president of Taxpayers for Common Sense, a fiscally conservative budget watchdog, who criticized the administration’s firing of more than a dozen federal inspectors general, who conduct nonpartisan oversight of agencies.

“Those are the people who should have been their allies. And instead, they’ve now alienated them,” he said.

Have you read them?

Cher Reveals Why Val Kilmer Never Called Her by Her Name — and His Nickname for Her

Did you know: When a Spider visits your home it’s a sign

Elon Musk’s trans daughter slams dad with fierce quote

Gabourey Sidibe Shares Her Favorite Memory from ‘Kitchen Table’ Wedding to Husband Brandon Frankel

News Feed

03.04.2025 13:51 Celebrities

Haley Joel Osment Reveals He Has Been Living With Sister Emily Osment After the L.A. Fires

03.04.2025 13:47 Spotlight

Find The Letters SIESTA Hidden in The Picture.

03.04.2025 13:43 Spotlight

Why do married couples not want to talk to each other?

03.04.2025 13:39 Stories

Deputy saved wife by pushing her out the way of crash

03.04.2025 13:35 Items

Do You Remember This Timeless Object? If You’ve Witnessed Changing Times, You Might Recall It. Explore The Fascinating Journey It Traveled

03.04.2025 13:32 Celebrities

Cher Reveals Why Val Kilmer Never Called Her by Her Name — and His Nickname for Her

03.04.2025 13:28 Tips & Tricks

Did you know: When a Spider visits your home it’s a sign

03.04.2025 13:25 Celebrities

Elon Musk’s trans daughter slams dad with fierce quote

03.04.2025 13:19 Celebrities

Gabourey Sidibe Shares Her Favorite Memory from ‘Kitchen Table’ Wedding to Husband Brandon Frankel

03.04.2025 13:15 Health

10 Cancer Warning Signs Women Often Overlook

03.04.2025 13:07 Beauty

My nana swears by applying baking soda to her face. Here’s her 3 methods and how they work

03.04.2025 13:03 Stories

Plus-sized influencer says airlines should accommodate people like her

03.04.2025 12:57 Stories

Mom Forced to Adopt Her Biological Twins Pushed to Change Surrogacy Laws. She Wept When New Act Went into Effect

03.04.2025 12:17 Animals

Incredible Footage Captures Moment Submarine Encounters Ancient Deep-Sea Creature Older Than Dinosaurs

03.04.2025 12:12 Life&Style

How True Love Shows Itself During Int.im.acy

03.04.2025 12:06 Stories

11-year-old dies because of online trend – now family is warning others about the household item that took his life

03.04.2025 12:03 Celebrities

Jean-Claude Van Damme Accused of Sleeping With Trafficking Victims From Romania

03.04.2025 11:58 Health

12 Early Warning Signs of an Aneurysm You Shouldn’t Ignore

03.04.2025 11:48 Stories

A desperate orphan with a suitcase knocked on the door of a restaurant. The owner was stunned when he learned her last name.

03.04.2025 11:11 Celebrities

Nikki Thot and Jamie Perkins’ kids – inside their life today

02.04.2025 17:51 Celebrities

Stars React to Val Kilmer’s Death at 65: Josh Brolin, Michael Mann, Jennifer Tilly and More

02.04.2025 17:45 Celebrities

Val Kilmer’s last ever Instagram posts as daughter confirms cause of death

02.04.2025 17:40 Stories

White mom going viral after birth of Black baby, but husband is white

02.04.2025 17:36 Joke

A man owned a small ranch in Montana.

02.04.2025 17:27 Health

5 Subtle Skin Changes That Could Signal Cancer

02.04.2025 17:22 Stories

The story of little Zaelynn, who died after parents left her in 109-degree closet

02.04.2025 17:18 Celebrities

Val Kilmer Wears Batman Mask in Final Instagram Video

02.04.2025 17:13 Celebrities

Tom Cruise Had an ‘Emotional’ Reunion with Val Kilmer in Top Gun 2 Before His Death: ‘He’s Such a Brilliant Actor’

02.04.2025 17:06 Items

If you see this hanging from the rafters of your home, here’s what it means

02.04.2025 16:55 Health

Doctors reveal the one bl00d type which has the highest risk of getting stomach canc3r

Exit mobile version